Making Existing Data More Useful for Malaria Programs 

A CCP-led study in Malawi shows how combining bed net and mosquito data can help malaria programs identify gaps in protection.
malaria
Photo: U.S. President's Malaria Initiative

When malaria programs try to protect people from mosquito bites, knowing where mosquitoes bite is only part of the picture. Programs also need to understand how people are exposed and where protection may be falling short.

“People are not protected just because insecticide-treated nets exist,” says Kaci McCoy, first author of a recent study published in Malaria Journal. “Protection is dependent on whether people have access to a net, whether they’re using it, whether it’s effective and whether the mosquito biting is actually happening at a time and in a place where the net can be helpful.”

The new study shows how combining data on people’s bed net access and use with information about mosquito biting patterns can help malaria programs identify gaps in protection. The research was conducted by a team working under Breakthrough ACTION, an eight-year USAID-funded project led by the Johns Hopkins Center for Communication Programs until spring of 2025.

The team brought together data from the CCP-led Malawi Malaria Behavior Survey (MBS), which captured people’s nighttime routines, including when they went indoors, went to sleep, woke up and used bed nets, with routine mosquito surveillance data collected by the U.S. President’s Malaria Initiative’s VectorLink project and its partners. One dataset showed when people were indoors, outdoors and protected by bed nets, while the other showed when and where mosquitoes were biting.

Putting the data together was only part of the challenge. Because the datasets had been collected for different purposes, the team had to decide how to align them and what additional context was needed to interpret the results. The paper documents those decisions and the assumptions behind the analysis, giving other programs a clearer path to using data they may already have.

The paper also illustrates the lasting value of data collected through USAID-funded programs. Even as the U.S. foreign assistance system has been largely dismantled and reorganized, existing data like those from the MBS and VectorLink projects can continue to inform public health decision-making.

In Malawi, the combined data revealed a striking gap. Researchers estimated that 87 percent of potential exposure to mosquito bites occurred while people were asleep, when bed nets could offer protection. Yet nets were estimated to prevent only 35 percent of potential exposure.

The behavioral data helped explain part of that gap. Only 39 percent of people had access to an insecticide-treated net, while 40 percent reported sleeping under one the previous night. The figures pointed to limited access as an important barrier to protection, rather than simply a failure to use nets. The team could therefore consider whether expanding access might be a more useful investment than focusing on behavior change alone.

The researchers also looked beyond access and reported use to consider the nets themselves. The last mass distribution campaign had taken place nearly three years before the survey, while durability data suggested that nets in the area lasted roughly two to three years. The timing raised the possibility that some nets might have reached the end of their useful life.

The paper includes a spreadsheet template to help other researchers combine similar data from their own programs. The estimates show patterns of potential exposure, not an individual’s precise risk, and results will depend on the data available in each setting.

“How can you leverage large, freely available datasets and make them programmatically useful?” McCoy says. “And this is how.”

Along with McCoy, “Integrating routinely collected mosquito vector and human behavioral data for malaria prevention: A case example in central region Malawi” was written by Allison Hendershot, Abdoulaye Bangoura, Leonard Dandalo, Michael Bride, Shadreck Mulenga, Akuzike Banda, John Munthali, Themba Mzilahowa, Sophia Kaufman, Stella Babalola, Shelby Cash, John E. Gimnig, Gabrielle Hunter, Bolanle Olapeju, Joseph Millward, Neil F. Lobo, Sarah Zohdy, Jenny Carlson Donnelly and April Monroe.

Subscribe to our monthly newsletter